Overview

The Otherwhere Post by Emily J. Taylor is a standalone YA dark-academia fantasy. It follows Maeve Abenthy, who’s lived under an alias since her father was blamed for a world-ending catastrophe. When she receives an anonymous letter declaring, “Your father was innocent,” Maeve joins the mysterious Otherwhere Post to learn scriptomancy. This is magical letter-writing that can cross worlds, and uncover the truth.

Magic

Scriptomancy is an inventive and richly layered form of magic. From ink-based spells to creatures formed from writing, the magic is fresh and intriguing. 

Setting

Crumbling libraries and haunted academic buildings deliver the perfect dark academia vibe.

Mystery

There’s a central whodunit that propels the narrative: was Maeve’s father truly at fault, or is something more sinister at play? The puzzle unfolds with care, rewarding readers.

Characters and romance

Maeve is a strong heroine with plenty of layers. She’s wary, independent, yet quietly yearning for connection. Her slow-burn dynamic with her mentor Tristan brings wit, tension, and warmth. Secondary characters like feisty roommate Nan add levity, although it would be nice if these were developed further.

Favourite features

• Inventive scriptomancy with atmospheric worldbuilding
• Emotional journey with believable growth
• Engaging slow-burn romance and tight mystery

The verdict

Immersive, intriguing and enjoyable - highly recommend